theuk.fyi
Scottish school leader questions planned mobile phone ban
Dr Lucy Hay, depute rector at Kelvinside Academy, argues that schools should help pupils learn to manage phone use rather than prohibit devices outright.
A senior leader at Glasgow’s Kelvinside Academy has criticised plans for a complete mobile phone ban in Scottish schools, arguing that pupils need to learn how to use technology responsibly rather than have devices taken away from them.
Dr Lucy Hay, the school’s new depute rector, said an outright prohibition risked making phones more attractive and would not prevent young people from finding ways around restrictions. She acknowledged that opposing a ban was not a popular position, but said she had confidence in pupils’ ability to act resourcefully.
At Kelvinside, pupils cannot use their phones during the school day. They put the devices in their schoolbags at the start of the day and are expected to leave them there until school ends. The school does not routinely confiscate phones. If a pupil misuses one, they may be asked to leave it at reception and collect it later.
Hay described the approach as a ban, although parents campaigning on the issue use the term for a stricter system in which phones are removed from pupils. She said staff are cautious about taking devices away and that incidents can instead prompt restorative conversations.
Her argument is that phones are part of the environment in which young people are growing up, and that schools should work out how to accommodate them. She said it was unreasonable to raise pupils in a setting where they were told they could not have phones, then expect them to manage independently as young adults without having learned how.
The debate comes amid concern about children’s wellbeing. Scotland’s parliamentary education committee heard that psychological support services are available from Primary 1, while young people are increasingly seeking help for anxiety and mental health difficulties. Phones and the effects of the Covid pandemic have both been cited as factors affecting children.
Hay said the pandemic’s effects may have weighed more heavily on adults’ concerns for young people than on the children themselves. She also recognised that mental health concerns have changed since before Covid, alongside shifts in parenting and the influence of phones and other technology.
She said pupils need to be in a good place to achieve academically. Her position is not that schools should ignore the challenges posed by phones, but that adults need to work out how to engage with them as part of school life.
Kelvinside is also developing its approach to artificial intelligence. The school has produced Artificial Intelligence At School guidelines. Rector Dan Wyatt said the system was intended to avoid rigid rules, with teachers able to hold their own positions.
Hay brings more than 30 years of experience in teaching, pastoral work and leadership in the UK and the United States. Her previous roles included work at George Watson’s College, St Columba’s School and Edinburgh Academy. She studied pharmacology at Aberdeen University and completed a PhD at Strathclyde University, researching drug delivery systems at Edinburgh’s Western General Hospital. She later taught biology near Chicago and, after returning to Scotland, trained as a counsellor.
Page details
- Section
- Schools
- Location
- UK
- Published
- 10 November 2026, 04:32
- Updated
- 11 November 2026, 00:29
Related stories
- Why more families are choosing home education
Experts say there are complex and varied reasons why more children are being taken out of schools.
- School sends minibus to collect children skipping class to play GTA VI
Ninestiles in Birmingham has also rejigged its mock exam timetable and offered prizes for youngsters attending school instead of staying home to play GTA
- Unopened Nottingham school could offer up to 60 specialist places
Nottingham City Council has approved entering a 125-year lease for Waterside Primary School, which could become an additional site for Rosehill School. The prop
- David Walliams books removed from Greater Manchester schools
A Greater Manchester academy trust has advised headteachers in its 59-school network to temporarily remove the author’s books from school libraries. The trust
- Study finds some Welsh secondary schools provide no religious education
A study by academics from Bangor University and the National Centre of Religious Education for Wales found that some secondary schools in Wales are not providin
- St Austin’s parents raise concerns over proposed academy trust move
Parents at the Liverpool primary school say a meeting with school and church representatives left questions about the educational benefits of joining St Joseph
- Merseyside parents fear proposed SEND reforms could weaken protections
Parents in Merseyside have raised concerns about planned changes to special educational needs and disabilities support. The reforms are described as proposals,
- Teacher barred over over-familiar messages to pupil
A panel found that a teacher’s messages to a pupil were over-familiar but had no sexual motive.
Information on this page is refreshed from the connected theuk.fyi services when the interactive page loads.
