theuk.fyi

theuk.fyi

Scientists propose early black-hole seeds could explain one Webb red dot

Researchers say a model in which a small primordial black hole grew by drawing in gas and dust could account for the properties of QSO1, an ancient object obser

Editorial illustration accompanying: Scientists propose early black-hole seeds could explain one Webb red dot

A team of researchers has proposed that small, early black holes could help explain some of the mysterious “little red dots” seen by the James Webb Space Telescope. Their study models one object as the product of a primordial black-hole seed that grew by drawing in gas and dust, but does not establish that such black holes exist.

The objects have been identified in deep-sky observations since 2023, with about 300 reported. They appear compact and red, and are observed as they were within roughly the universe’s first billion years. Some are so small in telescope images that they occupy only a single pixel.

The researchers, from Johns Hopkins University, focused on Abell 2744-QSO1. The object is seen as it was about 700 million years after the Big Bang and lies within Abell 2744, also known as Pandora’s Cluster. The cluster is described as a group of galaxies about four billion light-years from Earth; its gravity magnifies QSO1’s light.

Study co-author Loris Del Grosso told Metro that the dots were puzzling because they did not fit either of the obvious explanations. The team considered three ways QSO1 might have formed, according to co-author Valerio De Luca.

One possibility was that it formed directly as a heavy primordial black hole. De Luca said this explanation was ruled out because it would have left a detectable signal in the cosmic microwave background, the afterglow of the Big Bang. A second proposal, in which the object formed from smaller primordial black holes, was considered unlikely because of the complexities of the early universe.

The model favoured by the team instead begins with a lighter primordial black-hole “seed”. It could have accumulated gas and dust and grown rapidly, reaching a large mass within a few hundred million years. De Luca said the model can reproduce properties of well-studied dots such as QSO1.

The researchers describe QSO1 as containing hydrogen and helium, the first elements to form, alongside a swirling, very hot disc of gas and other material. Those features, the team says, make it appear relatively unspoiled and ancient compared with other little red dots.

The primordial-black-hole explanation remains a proposal, not a confirmed discovery. Del Grosso said the team intends to examine other red dots to see whether they also fit the model, while remaining open to alternative accounts.

One alternative is that a black hole formed through more conventional processes, such as the collapse of a galactic gas cloud, and is surrounded by a dense envelope of gas. Del Grosso said such a cocoon could absorb the black hole’s light and re-emit it, making the object glow like the surface of a cool star. In that case, the object might be a previously unrecognised kind of “black hole star”.

Other suggestions include short-lived giant stars and young galaxies forming stars at exceptional rates. Del Grosso said the explanations need not be mutually exclusive: a primordial black hole could, for example, sit at the centre of a black-hole star.

Further observations could help distinguish between the ideas, including by revealing how massive the objects are or how quickly they grow, Del Grosso said. The researchers’ findings were published in Physical Review Letters.

Page details

Section
General
Location
UK
Published
12 November 2026, 05:26
Updated
13 November 2026, 02:59

Related stories

Information on this page is refreshed from the connected theuk.fyi services when the interactive page loads.